Customer Favorites

Discover the designs everyone is raving about in our Bestsellers Collection—a curated lineup of our most-loved handmade items. These are the earrings, accessories, and gifts that consistently fly off the shelves, earn 5-star reviews, and bring our customers back for more.

From floral dangles and teardrop statement earrings to seasonal favorites and sports-themed accessories, this collection features pieces that blend personality with everyday comfort. Whether you’re shopping for yourself or searching for the perfect gift, these customer favorites are tried, tested, and truly adored.

All items in this collection are handmade in the USA, created in small batches, and designed to make a statement—whether bold or subtle. If you’re new to The Painted Pug, this is the perfect place to start. If you’re a returning customer, you might just spot your next favorite pair.

Need gifting ideas? These pieces are popular for birthdays, holidays, Mother’s Day, and more. Don’t forget to check out our Everyday Styles and Holiday Collections for even more fan-favorite finds.