Handmade Fall Earrings & Game Day Jewelry, Made in the USA

Lightweight dangle earrings you'll actually forget you're wearing — plus pumpkins, sunflowers, football, and Halloween styles that start conversations in the grocery store line. Every pair is designed and handmade in our Illinois studio with hypoallergenic surgical stainless steel hardware, and ships in 1–5 business days.

Shop Fall & Game Day

View all

Fall Earrings & Autumn Accessories

1 12
View all

Game Day Earrings for Football Season

1 12
View all

Halloween Earrings (Cute, Not Creepy)

1 12
View all

Customer Favorites

1 20
View all

Bundles & Gift Sets

View all

Why Shop with The Painted Pug?

  • Made, Designed, or Printed in the USA

    We’re proud to be a small business based in Illinois, creating every item right here in the USA. That means thoughtful craftsmanship, attention to detail, and real people behind every order.

  • ✨ Lightweight & Hypoallergenic

    If dangles usually pull on your earlobes by lunchtime, these won’t. Printed acrylic and wood keep them featherlight, and every earring uses surgical stainless steel hardware that sensitive ears can live with.

  • 🚚 Fast & Free Shipping Over $50

    No one likes waiting—or paying extra. Orders over $50 ship free, and we work fast to get your goodies out the door and on the way in 1-5 business days.

  • 🌟 7,000+ 5-Star Reviews

    Join thousands of happy customers who’ve trusted us with their gifts and goodies! With over 7,000 glowing reviews across Etsy, Amazon, and our website, you're in good hands.

Meet the Maker

Hi, I’m Sarah—the maker behind The Painted Pug. What started as a late-night creative escape turned into a thriving handmade brand filled with fun, meaningful jewelry and giftable goods. Every piece is designed and handmade right here in Illinois with care (and often a little pug supervision from Jax & Gracie 🐾). Whether you’re shopping for yourself or someone special, I hope our pieces add a little joy to your day.

Let customers speak for us

from 2110 reviews
Taupe Daisy Teardrop Earrings – Lightweight
Perfect

Perfect

Rhonda Savage
Pink Paisley Teardrop Earrings – Boho Floral
Loved all of my new earrings!! Shipping was very

Loved all of my new earrings!! Shipping was very fast!!

Lorie Blackburn
Mardi Gras Teardrop Earrings – Purple and Gold
BEAUTIFUL!!

BEAUTIFUL!! The color combination goes so well with so many of my outfits!!

Karen Hopple
Taupe and Navy Floral Teardrop Earrings – Lightweight
Love

Love them

Anonymous
Blue and Yellow Lemon Flower Dangle Hoop Earrings
Gave as a gift and she Loved

Gave as a gift and she Loved them!

Anonymous
Green and Gold Teardrop Earrings – Agate Style

SHE LOVED IT. COLRS MATCH TO GO WITH HER OUTFIT

BILL
Teal and Silver Dangle Earrings

SHE LOVED IT. GREAT COLORS.

BILL
Purple and Green Teardrop Earrings – Swirl
The earrings are very pretty and well made

The earrings are very pretty and well made. They are exactly what I was hoping for. They arrived quickly and were packaged with great care. Thank you, I plan to purchase more items in the future.

Laura Warren
Fall Gnome Golden Leaves Teardrop Earrings

love them

Anonymous
Flamingo Beach Dangle Earrings

Beautiful, fast shipping, lighter than they look so bot too heavy

Jessica
Mardi Gras Glitter Earrings – Purple and Green Teardrop Dangle
Mardi Gras Glitter Earrings

The Mardi Gras Glitter Earrings are beautiful and I love them.

Terri White
Sunflower and Wood Half Circle Acrylic Earrings
I love colors and print

I love colors and print.

Anonymous
Valentine's Day Teardrop Earrings – Rainbow Design
These earring are fun for sharing your Valentine

These earring are fun for sharing your Valentine spirit!

Crystal Mroz
Weiner Dog Dachshund Skeleton Halloween Dangle Earrings for Women

They are so perfect!!! Waiting for the right moment to wear them…

Gail
Fall Leaves Teardrop Earrings – Blue and Orange
Fall Leaves Teardrop Earrings

The blue and orange autumn leaves teardrop earrings are beautiful! They will go so well with fall sweaters and I’m looking forward to wearing them!

Karen Lee
2097
111

Fall Earrings, Handmade in Illinois

When the weather turns, so does your jewelry drawer. Our fall earrings lean into the good stuff — pumpkins, sunflowers, gnomes, fall leaves, buffalo plaid, and warm rust and bronze glitter — printed on lightweight acrylic and double-sided MDF wood so they never drag your earlobes down by 2pm. If you gave up on dangles because they hurt, start with our lightweight dangle earrings or our hypoallergenic styles for sensitive ears. Prefer something subtle? Our stud earrings start at $10.

Game Day Earrings for Football Season

Saturdays and Sundays are handled. Our football earrings and full game day collection come in team-color combos that work whether you are in the stands or on the couch — plus mascot and school spirit earrings for teachers, team moms, and the whole booster club.

Halloween Earrings That Aren’t Too Spooky

Our Halloween earrings are the wearable kind: ghosts, glitter pumpkins, witch hats, and spooky gnomes you can pair with a cardigan on a Tuesday. Want the whole look? Add a matching necklace or a fall graphic tee or sweatshirt.

Gifts She’ll Actually Wear

Most of our earrings land between $10 and $18, which makes them the easy answer for teacher gifts, hostess gifts, and stocking stuffers. Grab a bundle or gift set and let us do the coordinating. Everything ships from Illinois in 1–5 business days, orders over $50 ship free, and we have 7,000+ 5-star reviews from women who came for one pair and came back for six.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where are your products made?

All items are designed and finished in our Illinois studio. We also carefully source some base materials and components from trusted suppliers worldwide, then customize and package everything by hand to ensure quality and care.

How long will it take to receive my order?

Most orders are made and ship within 1–5 business days. Typical delivery times vary on where you live. Expect 3-7 days for delivery after your item has shipped. You'll get a tracking number as soon as your package is on the way! If you need your order by a specific date, please leave a note on the order and we will try our best to accommodate.

Will my Halloween earrings arrive in time?

Yes—if you order by around October 20th, standard shipping should get them to you before Halloween. We make and ship within 1–5 business days, then delivery usually takes another 3–7 days. If you're cutting it close, leave a note on your order and we'll do our best to bump you up.

Can I get earrings in my team's colors?

Our game day styles come in the most popular team-color combos, and many can be customized. Browse the Game Day collection first—if you don't see your colors, message us and we'll tell you what's possible.

Are your earrings hypoallergenic?

Yes! We use hypoallergenic stainless steel hardware in all our earrings to help keep sensitive ears happy. The gold earwires have a gold plating over the stainless steel.

Do you offer free shipping?

Yes! Orders over $50 ship free within the U.S.

Can I customize an item?

Absolutely! Many of our items can be personalized—just check the product listing or reach out if you have something special in mind.

Do you accept returns or exchanges?

Yes, we accept returns on non-personalized items if you contact us within 7 days of receiving your order. Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs, and original shipping fees are non-refundable.

Personalized items are final sale and cannot be returned.

If we made a mistake with your order, please reach out—we’ll make it right with an exchange or refund.


Do you offer gift packaging?

We don’t offer full gift wrap, but all items are packaged in a cute, gift-ready way—and you can add a note at checkout!



Can I get each pair of earrings individually wrapped?

We’re happy to individually box earrings if you’re purchasing multiple pairs for gifts. You now have the option to add a gift box and select the total number. Otherwise, we aim to minimize packaging to reduce waste while still ensuring everything looks pretty and gift-ready.